Down-Alternative Comforter (click to read review) | Materials (shell/filling) | Buy Now |
| #1 Ettitude | Bamboo | ettitude.com |
| #2 Takasa | Cotton and Wool | takasa.com |
| #3 Plushbeds | Cotton and Wool | plushbeds.com |
| #4 Resthouse | Cotton and Eco-Wool | resthousesleep.com |
| #5 Sleep and Beyond | Cotton and Merino Wool | sleepandbeyond.com amazon.com |
| #6 Ave Maria | Cotton and Alpaca | amazon.com |
| #7 Buffy Breeze | Eucalyptus/Recycled | buffy.co |
| #8 Piglet in Bed | Cotton and Merino Wool | pigletinbed.com |
| #9 Cariloha | Bamboo | cariloha.com |
| #10 Cozy Earth | Bamboo/Silk Bamboo/Bamboo | cozyearth.com |
| #11 Nest | Cotton/Silk | nestbedding.com |
| #12 Avocado | Cotton/Alpaca | avocadogreenmatress.com |
Are you looking for a natural and breathable blanket that can keep you warm all night long? Are you trying to avoid feathers and down for ethical and health reasons?
Currently, there is a growing trend to replace feather duvets and comforters with natural down alternative comforters which offer a better solution for a restful night’s sleep.
Organic Down Alternative Comforters have become popular for those looking for luxurious alternatives to traditional down comforters.
The benefits of organic down alternatives are many, including the fact that they are hypoallergenic and can be used in the same way as standard down comforters. They are also more sustainable towards our earth, animals, and humanity.
While conventional down is currently getting a bad rep for its unethical manners of harvesting feathers, organic down-alternative comforters can help you to sleep in comfort knowing that your blanket has been ethically made.
With the increase in respiratory illnesses like asthma, many people prefer feather-free blankets for both adults and children to avoid potential allergens and respiratory conditions while sleeping with down-filled blankets.
Click here to see our FAQ Section
The links in this article are affiliate links, meaning that if you click the link, I may get a small portion of the sale at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases with the links provided in this article. In no way does this affect our description or review of the following products.
Our Top Picks for Natural-Fiber Down-Alternative Comforters
#1 Ettitude Bamboo Comforter
What makes Ettitude a great organic down-alternative comforter?
A fully bamboo down-alternative comforter made perfectly for both the user and our planet. Bamboo is a sustainable resource that is grown without the use of pesticides or chemicals. It is also hypoallergenic and anti-bacterial, making it a great choice for those with allergies or sensitive skin.
The comforter is lightweight and breathable yet still warm and cozy. It is also machine washable and dryer safe, making it easy to care for. It’s soft, comfortable, and durable. The bamboo shell is very soft, making it tempting to use without a cover (don’t do it though)!
This comforter is a winner for us since the bamboo fibers provide a fluffy light feel while also maintaining warmth enough for all four seasons.
| Shell Material | High-quality bamboo fabric. |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | PETA approved bamboo Lyocell filling |
| Additional Features | Corner Loops Machine Washable Cooling effect for Hot Sleepers 2 Weight Choices (summer or winter) |
| Eco Impact | Certified Oeko-Tex Standard Produces 52% fewer carbon emissions Uses 500x less water than cotton Sourced from FSC-certified sustainable forests |
Advisory Details
Although Bamboo is a very sustainable crop utilizing much less water, the production of bamboo into fibers is very energy intensive compared with other natural fibers.
#2 Takasa Organic Cotton and Wool Duvet Insert
What makes Takasa a great organic down-alternative comforter?
This comforter is an investment that will last you for years to come! The Takasa Organic Down-Alternative Comforter is a great option for those who want a warm and cozy bed but want to maintain quality.
This down-alternative comforter is made with 100% organic cotton for the shell, free from harmful substances, making it hypoallergenic and safe for allergy sufferers.
The filling is made from GOTS-certified wool. You also have the choice between Perfect Comfort fill and Great North Warmth fill, depending on the temperature of your home, your climate, and your desired level of warmth.
The alternative down-alternative comforters are also made with a quilted design that provides excellent support for your body during sleep. What we liked most about this comforter is that it regulates temperature well, without overheating.
| Shell Material | Organic Cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | 100% GOTS-certified organic wool (naturally hypoallergenic) |
| Additional Features | Sturdy corner loops |
| Eco Impact | GOTS Certified Takasa plants one tree for every order Uses only Fairtrade cotton Ethically made |
Advisory Details
This down-alternative comforter is an investment for years to come since the price is higher than others. It is a very well-made product, but if the price seems a little high, it is best to first subscribe to their email list in order to be notified of any sales that the company is offering.
#3 Plushbeds Natural Wool Comforter
Made in the USA, this organic down-alternative comforter is made from a 100% Certified Organic cotton shell and filled with Oeko-Tex California Eco-Wool. Plushbeds maintains that their comforters are hypoallergenic, durable, and naturally antimicrobial. They also offer a luxurious feel that is both soft and warm, while also being light and airy.
They’re also eco-friendly because they are produced in a low-impact manner with minimal water usage during production; this is why they are considered an environmentally friendly choice for sleepers of all ages!
Plushbeds’ Organic Down Alternative Comforters have been tested by independent third-party laboratories to meet or exceed industry standards for performance and durability.
| Shell Material | Organic Cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | Oeko-Tex Standard 100 eco-wool |
| Additional Features | Regulates Temperature Very Well Hypoallergenic Made in the USA Custom-Made to Order |
| Eco Impact | Made with no chemical additives or dyes GOTS certified Wool comes from farmers dedicated to gentle flock management, humane wool shearing methods, and sustainable land use. |
Advisory Details
This down-alternative comforter runs a little heavy, so if you’re looking for something to soothe you while you sleep, this may be the option for you. If you prefer a lighter duvet, try a bamboo or silk option. Also, this comforter does not come with corner loops to secure the duvet cover.
#4 Resthouse Kakun Premium Eco-Wool Comforter
What makes Resthouse a great organic down-alternative comforter?
This is the ONLY down-alternative alternative comforter that we found which can satisfy both a hot and cold sleeper at the same time. Resthouse makes this Eco Wool Down-Alternative Comforter with split warmth levels depending on you and your partner.
Made with an organic cotton shell and filled with premium Eco Wool, Resthouse offers a 3yr warranty on their product.
Unlike synthetic materials such as polyester, this comforter is made from natural fibers that are easy on the environment. We love how this comforter is also machine washable and can be put in the dryer on low heat.
| Shell Material | 100% Organic Cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | Ethically Sourced Eco-Wool |
| Additional Features | Machine Washable Available in Split Temperatures Sturdy Corner Ties |
| Eco Impact | Oeko-Tex Standard 100 Cradle to Cradle certification Donates 1% for the Planet Ethical and Fair Trade Certified |
Advisory Details
Some users have found this comforters to be too hot, so be mindful of the weight you choose when ordering. It is a quality-made comforter that should be made as an investment for years to come. Subscribe to Resthouse before purchasing in order to take advantage of any sales and discounts that the company may be offering before buying this blanket.
#5 Sleep & Beyond Merino Wool Comforter
What makes Sleep & Beyond a great organic down-alternative comforter?
This down-alternative comforter by Sleep & Beyond is a comfortable and versatile alternative to traditional duvets. It provides a soft, cozy finish that is perfect for the spring and summer and can be used throughout the year.
It is ideal for anyone suffering from chemical sensitivities since it is made without the use of chemicals and surfactants. It has a natural lanolin smell since it is made with certified wool.
The shell material of this comforter is 400TC Sateen Organic Cotton which makes it feel soft against the skin. The filling is made out of organic merino wool ensuring a dry, soothing sleep environment resulting in less tossing and turning. This Comforter is a perfect option for anyone that has sensitivities to down, polyester, and feathers.
| Shell Material | Organic Cotton 400TC sateen finish |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | Fine certified organic merino wool |
| Additional Features | Four-season use Comes in a Cotton Carry bag |
| Eco Impact | Free of harmful chemicals, toxins, and synthetics. Cruelty-Free Wool GOTS certified 5% donation to local charity |
Advisory Details
Some users have found this comforters to be too hot for all four seasons. Also, make sure to use a quality enclosed duvet cover with this comforter as it can tend to shed small fibers after a while.
#6 Ave Maria Alpaca Duvet
What makes Ave Maria a great organic down-alternative comforter?
Alpaca wool is preferable for anyone sensitive to lanolin, which is present in sheep’s wool. It provides optimal heat insulation and comfort since the filling material is also hypoallergenic, making it suitable for sensitive skin types. The shell is made from smooth and crisp 400 thread count cotton with no synthetic layers or additives.
The Ave Maria Alpaca Duvet is an eco-friendly comforter that is perfect for anyone who wants to reduce their carbon footprint. It’s made from 100% natural materials. It is certified by the Oeko-Tex Standard 100, which means it’s free of harmful substances such as formaldehyde or dyes that can irritate skin or cause allergic reactions.
| Shell Material | 400TC Cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | 100% high-quality natural alpaca wool. |
| Additional Features | Hypoallergenic Lightweight Thermoregulating 4 Season-Use Alpaca is naturally flame-resistant |
| Eco Impact | Peruvian Producers |
Advisory Details
This is the only down-alternative comforter that we included in this list which is NOT made with an organic cotton shell. If you prefer organic cotton, it is best to choose another option. Despite the company advertising this as a four-season blanket, this comforter may be too warm for summer. Also, avoid washing this in the machine, it will ruin it.
#7 Buffy Breeze Comforter
What makes Buffy a great organic down-alternative comforter?
We included the Buffy Breeze comforter because of its super soft eucalyptus shell, and its recycled PET bottle filling, making this a truly sustainable option for our planet. If you’re trying to avoid polyester fill, this may not be the best option for you since it is essentially a recycled petroleum product, but from our research, the majority of users rave about the comfort of this blanket.
Buffy comforters are soft, breathable, and machine-washable. Plus, they’re hypoallergenic and free of harmful chemicals. And because they’re made of recycled materials, they’re gentle on the environment.
Buffy is so confident that you will love their down-alternative comforters that they offer a 7-night free trial and only charge you after the first week of use. If you still don’t like it after 100 nights, they will take it back and refund you.
| Shell Material | Eucalyptus TENCEL fibers |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | GRS-certified recycled fibers renewed into marshmallowy soft fill |
| Additional Features | Machine Washable Loops in every corner 100-night guarantee |
| Eco Impact | GRS-certified recycled fibers Eucalyptus Production require less water to produce Buffy Offsets CO2 emissions Donates Returned bedding |
Advisory Details
We wanted to include this comforter because of the unique recycled fibers. The recycled fibers are made of PET plastic bottles and are a petroleum-based product, so if you’re looking to avoid polyester, this may not be the blanket for you.
#8 Piglet in Bed Merino Wool Duvet
What makes Piglet a great organic down-alternative alternative comforter?
Piglet is an organic down-alternative comforter that is great for people who like to sleep with a duvet or comforter all year round. The 100% organic cotton shell and carded Merino wool regulates temperature throughout the seasons. This down-alternative comforter can be bought in two weights: 200g per square meter and 350g per square meter.
The Comforter is also free of dyes and chemicals perfect for those with allergies or those wanting to avoid using down feathers for health or humane reasons. The Piglet in Bed Merino Wool Duvet is a fantastic duvet set for children and adults alike as it is both hypoallergenic and machine washable.
| Shell Material | 100% organic cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | 100% merino wool |
| Additional Features | Corner loops Two available weights Machine Washable |
| Eco Impact | Naturally hypoallergenic Humanely sourced wool from Italian free-range, non-farmed Merino sheep flocks |
Advisory Details
They do accept returns up to 90 days, but the company insists that the return be made only on comforters that have not been used…so, it may be difficult to see if it’s right for you without sleeping in it for a few nights. We suggest you try a linen duvet cover to go with it, it’s highly durable for years to come and can be used in any season. I actually use mine alone without a duvet on the hottest nights of the year.
#9 Cariloha
What makes Cariloha a great organic down-alternative comforter?
Cariloha’s organic down-alternative comforter is made with a 100% luxurious blend of eco-friendly bamboo viscose. Bamboo is a truly sustainable crop that can regrow at a very quick rate compared to other crops such as cotton. It’s hypoallergenic as both the exterior shell and the interior stuffing are made entirely of bamboo.
What makes Cariloha’s organic down-alternative comforter so great is that it is naturally hypoallergenic and perfect for those with sensitive skin or allergies.
| Shell Material | Viscose from Bamboo |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | Viscose from Bamboo |
| Additional Features | Hypoallergenic Naturally antimicrobial Lightweight and breathable Year-round use |
| Eco Impact | Fraction of the water used in production Bamboo is a sustainable resource |
Advisory Details
Although bamboo is a great crop to grow without the use of pesticides and herbicides, it is VERY energy intensive to make it into fibers, this has an eco-offset that is not preferable.
#10 Cozy Earth Comforter
What makes Cozy Earth a great organic down-alternative comforter?
If you suffer from hot flashes or are trying to regulate your temperature better when you sleep, this is probably the best down-alternative comforter for you! Oprah has described this comforter as “the softest ever!”. The bamboo cover has a satiny feel, and the comforter keeps you evenly warm all night.
Cozy Earth’s organic down-alternative comforter is made with a bamboo shell and the choice between mulberry silk stuffing or bamboo stuffing. Mulberry silk is a unique type of silk made by silkworms that eat exclusively from leaves from the mulberry tree. It is a high-quality silk that is very soft and perfect for sleeping.
The cover is made with premium bamboo viscose, which is hypoallergenic and breathable. This comforter is best to dry cleaned by can be washed on a non-spin cycle.
| Shell Material | Viscose from bamboo |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | 100% Mulberry Silk or Bamboo |
| Additional Features | All-season breathability Corner loops Pill-resistant VERY soft Breathable |
| Eco Impact | Ethical Textiles Bamboo utilizes much less water in production Mulberry Silk is sustainable and has a low carbon footprint |
Advisory Details
If you’re buying the Cozy Earth down-alternative comforter, splurge and go for the silk-made interior, you WON’T regret it!
#11 Nest Silk Cloud Comforter
What makes Nest a great organic down-alternative comforter?
Nest Bedding’s Silk Cloud Comforter is filled with a blend of mulberry silk, making it a luxurious and environmentally friendly down-alternative comforter. This blanket is like a weightless cloud keeping you warm enough but never overheating.
The organic cotton shell is made from US-grown sources adhering to strict USA Organic guidelines. This combination of natural materials makes the Silk Cloud Comforter both comfortable and breathable, perfect for year-round use. The Nest Comforter is hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant, making it a great choice for those with allergies or sensitivities.
| Shell Material | 300TC 100% Organic Cotton |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | Mulberry Silk |
| Additional Features | hypoallergenic Temperature-regulating High quality grade 6A, 19 momme silk |
| Eco Impact | Third party tested toxin-free Fair Trade Certified OEKO-TEX Stewardship Council® certification |
Advisory Details
If you’re looking for a heavy blanket, this will NOT be the option for you. Silk will keep you warm, but feels light and airy when you sleep. Try this bamboo duvet cover for an added silky soft slumber.
#12 Avocado Alpaca Insert
What makes Avocado a great organic down-alternative comforter?
Avocado is known for its clean and toxin-free mattresses and sleep gear. This blanket is a great organic down-alternative comforter because it has an extremely soft and silky feel, yet it’s also very durable. The shell is made from 100% organic cotton with a percale weave. Alpaca-filled wool is extremely breathable, and it is quilted in a way that avoids bunching and shifting while in the duvet cover. The comforter comes in two weights, all-season, and light. They’re also incredibly durable and can last for years before needing replacement.
Avocado is convinced you will love their comforter; they offer a 100-night guarantee trial and a 1-yr warranty. Avocado also sells beautiful organic duvet covers made out of linen and cotton that are certified and naturally breathable.
Avocado is a climate-negative company, meaning that overall, the company reduces more greenhouse gasses than it produces. Avocado can ensure a healthy non-toxic product through its many certifications.
| Shell Material | 100% GOTS organic certified cotton percale |
| Filling Material (stuffing) | 100% alpaca fibers |
| Additional Features | Quilted to avoid bunching and shifting Comes in two weights: All season & lightweight 1 Yr warranty and 100-night trial |
| Eco Impact | GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certified 1% for the planet Forest Stewardship Council® certification MADE SAFE Certification |
Advisory Details
Since they offer many other non-toxic sleep goods, such as mattresses and pillows, and they have a 100-night trial, they tend to sell out of their stock. So, if you have time to wait for restock, it is totally worth it.
FAQ
What are down-alternative comforters often made out of?
The most common materials for down-alternative comforters are polyester and microfiber. Polyester is a synthetic fabric that is durable and easy to care for, yet is a petroleum made product which is a type of plastic. It is not breathable and can leave you waking up in sweat. Microfiber is a synthetic fabric that is soft and has a luxurious feel but is also a plastic byproduct.
Down alternative comforters that are made from natural fibers. They are more costly, yet a better alternative for those wanting a more breathable sleep.
What are the best materials for down-alternative comforters?
The type of material used in your down-alternative comforter will depend on your budget and personal preference. If you’re making the investment in a natural down-alternative comforter that will last you for years to come, it is best to go with an organic cotton shell. Organic cotton is produced with less water, zero pesticides/herbicides, and is often dyed with organic dyes.
The best filling for a down-alternative comforter will depend on how you sleep, your natural body temperature, your climate, and your sleeping partner.
What natural material makes the fluffiest down-alternative comforters?
A few different natural materials can be used to make down-alternative comforters. The most fluffy down-alternative comforter is bamboo. Wool, alpaca, and merino, make great stuffing, but come with a greater weight than bamboo.
Which Natural & Organic Down Alternative Comforters should I choose for Winter? Summer? Spring/Fall?
There are many factors to consider when choosing the right comforter for your home. The type of comforter, the climate you live in, and your personal preference all play a role in finding the perfect fit for you.
For Winter, you’ll want to choose a heavier weight comforter that will provide more warmth such as the all-season weight Avocado Alpaca Comforter.
For summer, the lightest comforter we came across was the Nest Mulberry Silk comforter, which can regulate temperature very well and keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night.
Spring and fall are transitional seasons, so you’ll want to choose a comforter that can be used in warm and cool weather. A mid-weight down-alternative comforter is a good option for these seasons: some of the best options are the Ettitude Bamboo Comforter and the Sleep and Beyond comforter.
Why Buy an Organic Down Alternative Comforter?
Buying an organic down-alternative alternative comforter is a no-brainer if you care about your health and the environment. Here are a few reasons:
1. You’ll sleep better knowing your comforter is free of harmful chemicals.
2. Organic down-alternative comforters are just as warm and cozy as conventional ones but without animal cruelty.
3. You’ll be helping to reduce your carbon footprint by choosing an eco-friendly option.
4. It is an investment that will last you years to come!
5. They are naturally breathable and hypoallergenic.
Why Avoid Polyester and Synthetic Materials?
Polyester and other synthetic materials are made from petroleum products, which are bad for the environment and your health. These materials are off-gas chemicals that can harm your respiratory system and trap heat and moisture, making you more likely to experience skin irritation, sweaty nights, and respiratory problems.
How do you wash a down-alternative-alternative comforter?
Your down-alternative comforter should always have a duvet cover. The easiest way is to remove it and wash it separately.
If you are buying a down-alternative comforter for children it is best to choose one that is machine washable. Often, down-alternative comforters can be washed on a gentle cycle to avoid shifting the filling, and then dried on low or air-dried. Each comforter has different wash instructions which MUST be adhered to.
We recommend using a mild detergent such as these laundry strips designed for sensitive skin.
Where to Start?
If you’re looking for ultra eco-sound sleep, it is best to find the right down-alternative comforter for you and your partner. If you’re unsure, start by selecting a company that is able to give you a trial period, such as Nest, Avocado, or Buffy.
Make sure to take materials into consideration based on your climate and your body type. Also, if you suffer from allergies or asthma, it is best to choose completely hypoallergenic materials such as alpaca, silk, or bamboo filling.
If you’re looking for more solutions for your home, take a look at our Best Eco-Finds on Amazon.
One Response
This is awesome, thanks for sharing!